Wow, what a mess.
First of all, I don't necessarily believe Christine Blasey Ford.
I know, I know---according to left-wing ideology, you're supposed to believe all women, regardless. Which is silly, because there are just as many crazy women as predatory men. (p.s. Left-wing goddess Hillary Clinton certainly didn't subscribe to the "believe all women" theory back when all of Bill Clinton's victims were coming forward in the '90s.)
In a November 2017 New York Times editorial, Bari Weiss made the point better than I:
Thursday, I was able to watch almost all of the testimonies of both Ford and Brett Kavanaugh. Having gone to sleep the night before on the couch with C-SPAN on, I, unfortunately for my attempt to be nonbiased, woke up to Ford's whiny, pseudo-little-girl "vocal fry"---that hideous cross between the old "Pat" character on SNL and Kourtney Kardashian that for some reason is being affected all over the place today by both women and some gay men. (Back in the '80s, Frank Zappa mocked a similar vocal phenomenon with his very popular "Valley Girl" song---so successful a parody that its shaming put an end to that style of speech for decades...until recent years.) So my initial reaction was: "Geez, the woman is MY AGE. Why is a grown, professional woman talking like that??"...I believe that the “believe all women” vision of feminism unintentionally fetishizes women. Women are no longer human and flawed. They are Truth personified. They are above reproach.I believe that it’s condescending to think that women and their claims can’t stand up to interrogation and can’t handle skepticism. I believe that facts serve feminists far better than faith. That due process is better than mob rule....
Other shallow, surface reactions: She seemed nice enough, but also neurotic and scattered. I didn't, based purely on personality, DISbelieve her, but her demeanor also, on the other hand, didn't particularly inspire confidence.
As for the meat of her testimony: Ford says that 4 other boys and 2 other girls were at the party at which she was attacked. Of these 6 people, not ONE says that they remember anything about a gathering such as this one, much less about a sexual assault taking place. And one of the girls, "Leland," was someone who was, and still is, a friend of Ford's. Leland even sent Ford a text recently, apologizing for having no memory of the entire event and for not being able to corroborate her story.
The fact that NO ONE else alleged to have been there, including a female friend still close to Ford today, remembers such a party is the main reason that I don't necessarily believe Christine Blasey Ford.
Other, more minor reasons:
(1) Ford doesn't remember how she got to the party, or how she got home. (According to her written testimony, she didn't live close to the house in question, so she didn't simply walk there or walk home.) In my own experience, and from what I've read about how most others process traumatic experiences, the victim will usually play and re-play everything about the event over and over and over again in their mind, trying to figure the whole thing out, how it could have been avoided, etc.
(2) I have been actually raped (in 2000, at age 35), which doesn't apply to the Ford case. But my own experience with a high-school "assault" took place at a Friday night school Halloween Haunted House put on by our Drama department when I was 15, the same age as Ford was. I was in the Drama dept and part of the cast, dressed up like a ghoul that popped out of a coffin and chased people. A guy that I liked came through the haunted house (held on the stage/backstage of our school auditorium), along with 3 of his friends; they were drunk. I popped out of the coffin, made spooky noises and moved toward them... They all four then surrounded me and started roughly groping me---boobs and, yes, trying to stick their fingers into my vagina (which was hard to do through whatever "scary" costume I had on, but they tried. It did hurt a little.). It was a Haunted House, completely dark, lots of weird music/noises and people milling about. Nobody noticed what was happening to me, which went on for about 30 seconds. And then another group of kids came up behind my attackers, and the guys moved on down the line. Afterwards, I thought, "That was weird." And it was the first time that anyone had ever touched my vagina (albeit through my clothes), so, at 15, I also wondered, "Am I supposed to have sexual feelings about this?" (I didn't.)
I do equate what happened to me at the Haunted House with the same type of thing that happened to Ford: At a high-school party with alcohol, and with drunk guys, one guy (allegedly Kavanaugh) jumped on Ford and groped her through her clothes. The other guy in the room (allegedly Mark Judge) laughed and jumped on top of both the male and female on the bed---which sounds like he thought the whole thing was a lark and a roughhouse rather than a truly scary experience for the woman --- allowing Ford to escape to the bathroom, after which the two guys stumbled back drunkenly down the stairs.
I didn't go to parties in high school (nerdy paper editor, not one of the "cool" kids --- which in my early '80s small-town high school were jocks and cheerleaders; there weren't any goths in small-town Texas yet), but I did go to many drunken parties in college. At which there were lots of gropings and flashings of body parts---dicks and boobs and asses galore. Sorry, but when young, drunken people get together, such things happen.
(3) When discussing her "trauma," Ford said that one symptom of her claustrophobia that allegedly resulted from the high-school event was a fear of airplanes and flying. Yet at the testimony on Thursday, it was revealed that she regularly (dozens of times) has flown to Hawaii, Polynesia, etc., for both research AND vacations. Ford also didn't remember that members of the Senate Judiciary Committee had offered to fly out to interview her at her home, which they had.
(4) I looked up "Christine Blasey Ford" on Wikipedia. She graduated her private high school in 1984, got her BA in 1988 from UNC at Chapel Hill, Master's from Pepperdine in 1991, and doctorate from USC in 1996. In my personal experience and based on knowledge of other troubled people's lives, which of course doesn't apply to everyone but is a general indication, emotional trauma translates into trouble focusing and applying oneself to a goal. Ford, on the other hand, had no trouble proceeding on the exact expected timeline for her life as an academic. (Good for her! However, real trauma is real trauma and almost always slows you down.)
(5) Ford claims she has no political agenda. Yet she has attended at least 2 public protests against Trump since his election.
(6) Senate Judiciary member Diane Feinstein received information about Ford's accusation back in July. If it were so credible, why hold out with the info until the last minute? Politically suspicious.
As for Kavanaugh:
Surface reactions (dating back to when Trump first announced him as candidate for Justice): The guy seemed to me like, yes, an elite prep-school "goody-goody" asshole who partied a lot but tried to maintain a good face before family and community. Maybe he DID black out at a gathering in the summer of 1982 and jump on top of Christine Blasey Ford. But no one else at said gathering, including a current female friend of Ford's, remembers anything about such a party with Kavenaugh in attendance. In short, there's NO PROOF. You don't destroy a man's reputation based on someone's faulty, and perhaps overly heightened/exaggerated, recollections of "abuse."
[Full disclosure: I'm a bi female, and a feminist, with a Master's degree in English who works as a science editor for peer-reviewed publications. I voted for McCain in 2008 (Hillary in the 2008 Democratic primary), Obama in 2012, and Trump in 2016.]


















